Note: This site has moved to a new URL:
http://webpages.charter.net/djhalnon/
Please bookmark it! You will be sent there in 10 seconds.

1453: Constantinople Falls

The Middle Ages are said to have ended in 1453. There are actually several events which took place in that year, that support this otherwise-arbitrary benchmark — but none is more important than the fall of Constantinople & the end of the Byzantine Empire, the last vestige of the ancient state of Rome.

The Eastern Roman Empire

The Roman Empire did not come to an end in the early 6th century, as many people believe, when the line of Roman Emperors in the west — with their capital in Rome itself — came to an end. The Roman Empire lived on, based from its eastern capital in Constantinople (formerly the Greek town of Byzantium). For nearly a thousand more years, it carried on the Roman state. The people of the "Byzantine Empire" called themselves Romans, & for a very long time, their "official" language remained Latin, the tongue of the ancient Romans. (Greek remained in common use, though, & gradually displaced Latin, over the last half of the Byzantine Empire's life.)

Under Emperor Justinian, with the help of his general Belisarius, the Eastern Roman Empire nearly reconquered what had been the Roman Empire, in the 7th century. But this was the height of Byzantine power, & the Empire would only grow smaller, thereafter. The Moslems assailed the Byzantines in the Middle East, capturing Egypt, northern Africa, & eventually Palestine & Syria. In the Balkans & Illyria, Germanic, Slavic & Altaic invaders pressed the edges of the Empire. Over the course of centuries the Empire was squeezed, and grew ever smaller.

With so many enemies ringing it, the Empire managed to cling to life by playing rival groups off on each other. They raised foreign policy to an artform, & developed a finely-tuned form of statecraft which was quite ingenious. This was documented by Emperor Constantine VII Porphyrogenitos, in a memoir he called De administrando imperio, or "On the administration of the Empire." But, as foreign policy grew subtle & complex, so too did domestic politics. Factions of the Empire rivaled one another, constantly trying to gain authority at another's expense. The office of Emperor changed hands sporadically, usually through palace revolts led by generals who used their armies to enforce their authority — just as Julius Caesar & so many other classical Roman Emperors had done.

Byzantium's prominence & importance lay in its location, at the crossroads of two continents (Europe & Asia). A trading center from the time of its founding some 5 centuries BCE, it remained a commercial center ever after, & therein lay both the source of its power, & the cause of its vulnerability. Trade within & around the city provided tariff revenues for the Emperors; at the same time, it seemed a gold mine for potential conquerors.

The Waning Byzantine Empire

The Byzantine Empire had been on a long, slow decline, for centuries. It faced near-extinction on several occasions, barely rescuing itself from destruction on more than one occasion. Perhaps the most notable of these occasions, prior to the 15th century, was when the Danishmend Turks, who controlled most of Anatolia in the 11th century, captured Nicaea, not far from the far shore of the Bosporus. The forces of Kilij Arslan, warlord of the the Danishmends, were literally in sight of the spires of Constantinople. Emperor Alexius II Comnenus, fearing for the future of his people, asked the Pope (Urban II) for aid from the Christians from the west. The result of this was the calling of the Crusades, which I discuss at length, elsewhere.

Another occasion during which Byzantium was almost destroyed, was the Fourth Crusade. The leaders of the Fourth Crusade were heavily in debt with the merchants of Venice, when they financed their expedition to the Holy Land. As partial payment for that debt, the Venetians demanded that the Crusaders attack Constantinople, their main competitors in commerce. After capturing the city, seizing the Emperor, & replacing him with one of their own (Baldwin Count of Flanders), the Crusaders became embroiled in Byzantine politics. Some Byzantine factions allied with the westerners, & cooperated with their new regime. The descendants of the Comnenus family, which had held the Imperial Crown for almost two centuries, fled to a Greek city in northern Anatolia, called Trebizond, & set up a rival Empire. Another faction in the Greek mainland set up its own Empire.

Eventually the Crusaders were driven out & the Fourth Crusade came to a rather inglorious end, without ever coming near the Holy Land that they'd ostensibly planned to save. The Imperial Crown returned to Byzantine hands — although the new state at Trebizond lived on (it maintained friendly relations with the rest of the Empire & could be called a subject state).

Arrival of the Osmanli Turks

An Altaic tribe, the Osmanli Turks, arrived from central Asia, in the east of Anatolia, in the middle of the 14th century. They had been hemmed in by the Tatars & other Altaic/Turkic tribes who were on the warpath in other regions. The Osmanli settled into Anatolia & made it their home; they built a rather ragtag coalition, mainly of Turks of their own tribe, but with a few war-bands from other Turkic tribes as well as some native mercenaries, under the banner of their leader Osman (for whom they are named).

The Osmanli, or Ottoman, Turks & their coalition drove the Byzantines almost completely out of Anatolia by the end of the 14th century. In 1402 they had crossed into the Balkans & taken up residence to the north of the Greek mainland, not far from Constantinople, & in fact laid siege to that magnificent ancient city. But at about the same time the Tatars, under their great leader Tamur (or Timur, or Tamurlane, the subject of a pair of plays by Shakespeare's contemporary Christopher Marlowe) swept into Anatolia & attacked the Ottomans from the east. They had to raise their siege of Constantinople, to meet this threat, & Tamur defeated them. It took several decades for the Ottoman regime to rebuild itself & move its capital back to the Balkans, to resume their war on the Byzantines.

On a number of occasions, Christian realms within Byzantium's sphere of influence, such as Hungary & Serbia, came to Constantinople's defense. But the Serbs were defeated at the Battle of Kosovo, & the Hungarians were unable to stop the Ottomans. When he came to power in 1451, the Ottoman sultan Mehmet II immediately began his campaign against Constantinople.

Constantinople Falls

On May 29, 1453, the Ottoman Turk artillery finally breached the massive outer walls of the city, & entered & sacked Constantinople. The Byzantine Empire had come to an end. The body of the last Emperor, Constantine XI Paleologus, was never recovered. Mehmet moved his capital to the ancient city, & it became known by its Turkish name, Istanbul. Within a few years, the Ottomans had captured all of Greece & most of the Balkans, up to the fringes of Hungary to the northwest.

The Trebizond Empire of the Comnenus family, oddly enough, had managed to survive the initial growth of the Ottoman regime; but within a decade after the fall of Constantinople, they were overcome, & became subjects of the Ottoman Sultan. That line of Emperors, too, came to an end.

The “Roman Mandate” Lives On

Despite the fall of Constantinople, & the end of the line for the Paleologus and Comnenus imperial families, the "Roman mandate" survived. For, Grand Duke Ivan III of Moscow had married a daughter of Emperor Constantine XI, & after his (apparent) death, styled himself the "new" Roman emperor. It is from this tradition that the Russian rulers later called themselves tsars ("Caesars"), & acquired the surname "Romanov." Their line, & thus the Roman mandate, lived on until the deaths of Tsar Nicholas II & his family, during the Bolshevik Revolution.

Significance of Constantinople's Fall

For centuries the city of Constantinople had a tremendous reputation. It was one of the wonders of the world, a center of commerce & learning, a shining beacon amid the chaos of invasions & regimes that assailed one another, all around it. The city was majestic, & many considered it a mystical or magical place. For most of the Byzantine Empire's life, while Byzantine territory was lost to invader after invader, most believed the city itself could not fall. The very name of the city sparked fear even in the hearts of some of Byzantium's mightiest foes. For example, although he could have done much the same thing as Mehmet II had done, his father had refused to attack the city.

The city's impending doom, just prior to its fall, had encouraged even some of its oldest enemies — the Italian trading centers of Venice & Genoa — to rally to its defense. (They feared the Ottomans taking the place of the Byzantines as their competitors — they didn't want the Byzantine fleet to fall into the hands of the "savage" Turks.) Neighboring states such as Serbia & Hungary, with whom the Byzantines hadn't always been friendly, had similarly come to its aid. No one, not even most of Byzantium's enemies, it seems, wanted the glorious city of Constantine to fall.

When Constantinople was sacked, the sound reverberated around the world. While the "Roman mandate" had moved to Moscow, the original Roman state — in its heyday the greatest empire the world had ever seen, a state which had endured for some fifteen centuries — came to an end. This did not go unnoticed. Constantinople's fall was lamented far & wide; many reacted with shock & even disbelief. The Pope sent emissaries there, just to find out if it really had fallen.

So profound was the respect for the Byzantine state, that the Ottoman sultans did not dismantle the Empire's government. Rather, they assumed control of it, and maintained the bureaucracy which had taken a thousand years to build up. Of course, this led to some problems, particularly under weak Sultans, but it appears the Ottomans wanted to have pretty much the same kind of state the Byzantines had ruled.

The Ottoman state endured into the 20th century, after having gotten involved in World War I as an ally of Germany & Austria-Hungary. As a result of that War, the Ottoman Empire lost a good deal of territory — including nearly all of its Balkan lands, Syria, & Palestine. Shortly thereafter the office of Sultan was set aside, the capital moved to Ankara in the interior of Anatolia, & it became the modern republic of Turkey.

End of the Middle Ages

The fall of Constantinople — among other things — brought an "official" end to the Middle Ages. The Middle Ages are called that because they were "in the middle," the long period of transition from the great classical states of Greece & Rome, to the modern nation-states of Europe. When the city of Constantine fell, the last vestige of a classical state (Rome) was gone, & the period of "transition" concluded.


Back up to Dennis's “Greatest Moments in History”

Back up to Dennis's Home Page.