Homeowners contest property tax assessments
18 November 2026
Across the United States, homeowners have the legal right to contest property tax assessments they believe are too high. The process, however, can be complex and varies significantly based on state, county, and local jurisdictions. Understanding the steps involved in challenging an assessment is crucial for homeowners seeking to lower their property tax burden.
Assessment Appeals: A Patchwork of Local Rules
Every homeowner in the U.S. has the right to appeal or contest their property tax assessment through a formal process with their local assessment authority or appeals board. The procedures, forms, and deadlines for contesting a property tax assessment are determined locally, leading to a patchwork of rules across the country. Homeowners must adhere to their specific jurisdiction's guidelines, which can include filing a notice of protest, submitting official forms, and appearing before assessment boards. The first step is usually contacting the local assessor's office to understand the local process.
Common Grounds for Appealing a Property Tax Assessment
Most homeowners contest assessments because they believe the assessed market value is too high or that the assessor used incorrect property data, such as incorrect square footage, lot size, or the number of bedrooms and bathrooms. Common reasons for appeal include:
- Errors in fact: Incorrect data about the property, such as size or condition
- Errors in judgment: The assessor's estimate of market value is too high
Gathering Evidence for a Property Tax Appeal
To successfully contest a property tax assessment, homeowners need to gather compelling evidence. Typically, this includes at least three recent sales of comparable properties with lower sale prices than the assessor's estimated market value, plus documentation correcting any factual errors in the records.
The Importance of Timely Action
Many jurisdictions offer an informal review or discussion with the assessor to try to resolve disputes before filing a formal appeal. However, homeowners must act quickly, as there is usually a short window—often 30 to 45 days from receiving the valuation notice—to notify the assessor or appeals board of their intent to contest the assessment. Sending a formal "notice of protest" or appeal letter promptly while gathering evidence is crucial.
New York State's Multi-Tiered Appeal Process
1. Administrative Review: Outside New York City and Nassau County, homeowners file Form RP-524 "Complaint on Real Property Assessment" with the assessor or the local Board of Assessment Review.
2. Judicial Review: If dissatisfied with the Board's decision, homeowners can pursue a low-cost Small Claims Assessment Review (SCAR) or tax certiorari proceedings in State Supreme Court.
Los Angeles County's Informal and Formal Appeal Options
In Los Angeles County, homeowners have two main options for contesting a property's assessed value:
1. Informal Review: Homeowners can request a review with the Assessor, including a "Decline-in-Value" review for annual bills.
2. Formal Appeal: Homeowners can file with the county Assessment Appeals Board; those appealing Supplemental, Adjusted Supplemental, Adjusted Property Tax Bills, or Escaped Assessments must file within 60 days of the mailing date on the Notice of Assessed Value Change, the mailing date on the tax bill, or the bill's postmark date, whichever is later.
Cook County, Illinois: Multiple Levels of Appeal
In Cook County, property owners can appeal to the Cook County Assessor or the Cook County Board of Review. If dissatisfied with the Board's decision, they can further appeal to the Illinois Property Tax Appeal Board within about one month of the Board of Review's final determination, or alternatively file a tax objection in state circuit court within 165 days after the due date of the second property tax installment.
Familiarizing Yourself with Local Procedures
To successfully contest a property tax assessment, homeowners must familiarize themselves with the specific procedures, forms, and deadlines in their jurisdiction. This may involve checking the assessor's records, obtaining the property tax card, and ensuring the official description of the home is accurate. Consulting with a property tax professional or real estate attorney can also provide valuable guidance.