The Ministry of Abel McEwen, D.D.
October 22, 1806 — September 7, 1860

The church has helped to restore the portrait of Abel McEwen.  And I’ve been asked — in my capacity as Historian — to write a few lines about this man’s life with First Church.  But how do you put 54 years into just a few lines?

McEwen graduated from Yale in 1804, having studied with some of the leading theologians of the time.  When the invitation to come to New London was issued to him, McEwen replied, “I have sought divine direction and the advice of pious and judicious counselors … Hoping that the Church and Society have both formed just opinions of my theological sentiments, of my qualifications and character as a preacher of the gospel, as a man, and as a candidate for the pastoral charge; relying on your prayers for my faithfulness, on the countenance and assistance with which you can afford me in discharging the duties of a clergyman at this trying day, and on your candour and charity to forgive the imperfections of my life and performance, and praying for the direction and support of divine Grace, I comply with your invitation.” 

When he’d been with us a short time, he discovered that many of his parishioners were largely "unchurched".  This is something that many new pastors probably understand.  He could have been discouraged, but he decided to make lemonade.  His sermons were lessons that built a strong foundation — something that his congregation hungered for.  A mid-week prayer meeting was begun — and a Wednesday evening lecture that he maintained throughout his 54-year ministry.   Rev. McEwen's Portait

McEwen was an interesting mix of conservative theology with a liberal bent.  Congregational churches had been joined by other Protestant sects — Baptists, Episcopalians, Methodists — but there was still no formal Roman Catholic presence in the community.  When McEwen learned that a French bishop was visiting a neighbor and friend over the Sabbath, he opened the doors of First Church for a Roman Catholic service — said to be the first such service to be held in a house of worship in New London. 

McEwen was a reformer who pushed the community to abandon the vices common to a port city and to embrace the Sabbath and keep it holy.  He hated slavery, but he chose not to turn his back on slaveholders, choosing instead to side with those who thought it possible for slaveholders to be Christians.

McEwen’s influence was also felt beyond the New London parish.  He was a prime mover in the Home Missionary movement.  Many communities in Connecticut were seen to be drifting away from the true way — the congregational church. Churches in many towns stood vacant or were opened only for occasional services.  When he came to this community, he was the only settled pastor in an area 12 miles by 50.  In 1815 McEwen petitioned the General Association of the State to establish a society to restore the church in those communities where it had lost its presence.  The Association agreed, and it fell to McEwen to oversee the effort.  And not too many years later, there were a dozen settled pastors in the same area.

People who didn’t know him well had the impression that he was a cold intellectual — at least one of his fellow pastors referred to him as “Iceberg Abel.”  But people discovered that he was actually an excellent story teller and a man of considerable wit.  Take the time he invited the Rev. Jared Avery of Groton to accompany him to an association meeting: Dear Brother — My black pony starts for Griswold tomorrow morning, at 8 o’clock. Ballast wanted. A. McEwen.

He had a number of invitations to leave First Church — to move on to bigger and better things — but he declined them all.  His call, as he saw it, was to be a parish minister — the pastor of First Church — and New London was the better for his commitment to that call.

Did the Search Committee of 1806 make a good choice?  I’d say they did.  And when McEwen died in 1860, the whole community came out to mourn his passing.  And it’s fitting that we honor the man and that Search Committee today. 

Peter Hawkins
Church Historian

The plaque which hangs in First Church's sanctuary reads: In Memory of Rev. Abel McEwen, STD, 1780-1860, Pastor of this First Church of Christ, 1806-1860.  A wise, faithful, brave preacher of strong intellect and quick sympathies.  His influence was powerful in the town and county.  Out of his care for feeble churches grew the Connecticut Home Missionary Society, the first of the kind in the United States.  "Repairer of the breach; restorer of paths to dwell in."  Isaiah 58:12